Only registered wreckers can view this page.

Please login or register to access the page.

The Requiem for Niccolo Machiavelli -team is looking for your ideas and comments.

Join and show your support for Requiem for Niccolo Machiavelli .

General Ideas

Created at August 27, 2008
Created by Gary R Briones
Deadline Not set
Shots given 3
Reference media

Thumbs ranking

Jani Salomaa What are we supposed to comment on?
Poll_bar
1/100%

Description

Feed back as to the interest in this (these) films.


You must login or register to give a shot

Shots

Order by
Sanaleikkiblogi_schatten_thumb
Mike Pohjola October 12, 2008 20:14 0 Thumb-ups
Add to Favorites

Machiavelli or Sun Tzu?

Hi!

Could you describe your core idea in further detail? You keep saying you want to adapt Machiavelli's The Art of War, but that makes little sense. Machiavelli wrote The Prince, which is a book about politics, and governing a city state (democracy, taxes etc). The Art of War was written by Sun Tzu, and that one's about military tactics and strategy (siege engines, morale etc).

Either one would make an interesting basis for a tv series, perhaps feturing a longer story divided into thematically complete chapters. Occasional quotations from the original text. It could make for heavy, masculine, HBO style drama.

Jump to comment form

Comments

Jani Salomaa October 18, 2008 16:30 Flag

Mike, Macchiavelli also wrote books other than 'Il Principe'. One of of the lesser known of them is Art of War (Dell'arte della guerra).

Sun Tzu's has the 'historical copyright' to the name, though.

Gary R Briones October 18, 2008 08:27 Flag

It main focus would be Machiavelli (Hence the name) however, incorporating some of Sun Tzu's work would not be beyond the scope of this project.

You must login or register to comment

Jani Salomaa October 10, 2008 02:18 1 Thumb-up
Add to Favorites

What are we supposed to comment on?

Your production has an interesting theme, but that doesn't exactly give the Wreck A Movie community much to work with.

If you give us no direction, we'd just have to guess everything. General ideas is NOT what this community does well. It is at it's best with focused, inspiring tasks. Maybe you should try that before quitting..

Macchiavelli, though, deserves a good requiem. He is still mistakenly referred in International Relations literature as the originator of cold-hearted 'realpolitik'. Too few writers realize he has to be situated in his time and place. But some of his writing has relevance to this day.. For example, military leaders should still heed his advice and avoid using mercenary soldiers, for their allegiance is to the dollar, not the cause.

Jump to comment form

Comments

Atte Joutsen October 16, 2008 08:01 Flag

Nicely commented Jani. You pinned down the the facts for successful collaboration:
1) The more you give to the community the more you recieve
2) Give the community inspiring material
3) Make the tasks well defined and make them focused. You can set several tasks to cover a large area in the production
4) Invite people and market your production also on other sites than WAM.
5) Be excited about your production, the excitement is contagious
6) Have fun, because after all, that is why we are here. Having fun with film productions and your friends :)

Gary R Briones October 15, 2008 20:52 Flag

sorry, been away for some time... i am going to make new tasks that actually are clear... i promise!

You must login or register to comment

100_1844_thumb
Gary R Briones September 02, 2008 15:10 Production Leader 0 Thumb-ups
Add to Favorites

Has no one any feelings about Machiavelli ?

I had opened this up for "General" comments, but it seems that there is a total lack of interest. I will take the "production" down in a few more days, as it seems, doing this kind of film really, has no following. Oh, well, i guess that is the way the cookie crumbles.

Gary

Jump to comment form

Comments

Oskar Lönnberg September 18, 2008 19:52 Flag

That demo had something, but I feel empty after it. I need to watch it again. But this thread and film idea has certainly made me interested in Machiavelli. I need dwell deeper into his work.

Atte Joutsen September 18, 2008 17:50 Flag

That was _interesting_. Cacophonous at times and clear at times. I think I got something you wanted to tell with the video.

Gary R Briones September 18, 2008 17:21 Flag

I have put together a "very rough" concept video. The link is here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqBHCe1lPNQ

I will be posting additional tasks for the "real" work soon.

This particular piece is much more abstract then i plan the rest of the film to be. (it is my own weakness, the whole interpretative thing) Additionally, it is taken from "The Prince" and not art of war.

However, having said that, i have a good idea where i want to take this, and i will be posting more information and tasks shortly. (including- finding some "actors" and perhaps some one to help share in the editing. Of course all of this will follow my detailing exactly the approach i plan to take.

In the mean time, you can go here to get an English copy of the book- (that is the prince)

http://www.archive.org/download/prince_librivox/prince_librivox_64kb_mp3.zip

Gary R Briones September 16, 2008 04:23 Flag

I agree! That is the reason why i would like to do this film. Some people, heap praise on his works, while, (as you said) for the time they may have been a correct way of thinking, and looking at the world, today, there should be other options. That is were the first idea of the Mafia having the conversation comes in. ..and perhaps as an introduction to another part, we could have a group of wall-street types having a similar conversation.

gary.

Timo-Heikki Mäkelä September 16, 2008 03:55 Flag

I've read Macchiavelli's Prince, although I really don't remember much of it anymore. What I recollect is, that, despite it still being considered a masterpiece in politics, Macchiavellis ideas are very much in doubt, when it comes to ethics.

Basically his idea is: "Let them hate, so far as they fear."

That's basically a very rude militaristic way of thinking politics, which can be seen quite reasonable under the extreme uncertainty and volatility, which was the environment Macchiavelli lived in like But fitting the same rules of thinking into the relatively calm environment of today's world would be complete barbarism and cause major losses of wealth to the community by pressing people under practical totalitarism and fear.

Now, don't understand me wrong. Theory of decision making happens to be my specialty and I'm also a reserve military officer, so I can see very much point in his ideas even today - but only under some very extreme conditions. Such may be even very close. Only a few minutes before writing this reply I was discussing the extreme volatility of global financial markets today. Such volatility may well lead to something, where Macchiavelli's way of thinking may well appear the only possible one. But if so happens, that'll only be, because we people haven't been clever enough thinking in more intelligent ways of conducting policy. It shouldn't be a necessity, except when we've already screwed our politics somehow else.

I'd squeeze what I mean into something like: "If we humanity won't turn intelligent enough, we'll become all animals."

Gary R Briones September 15, 2008 19:49 Flag

Currently I am working on a concept piece to generally outlay the Idea. But, to answer you question more directly, I was thinking of adapting his books into a series of short films. What this means, is that the narration and plot devices he uses to tell his stories would be the same, but perhaps updated. ex: In "Art of War" Machiavelli uses a conversation between three nobles to outline his thoughts on warfare, well, why not have the same "type" of conversation but between three mafia members? Additionally, these would be the segue pieces between abstract-literal episodes of his ideas. ex: After a short conversation between several mafia members, the film cuts to another place-time showing massing armies ready for battle, with indication to how they are formed into battle lines, and how they are ordered by the their captains.

However, as i said, i will be working on a short demo, and then i will update the outline on the front page to redirect those interested.

Atte Joutsen September 11, 2008 11:25 Flag

Gary put out the production news:
"At the moment, I am working on a short "preview" film, that could be used as a template of sorts to get people's brain juices flowing. I hope to have something up in the next few weeks. So, keep tuned!!!!"

I hope we'll see some inspiring stuff soon!

Angela R. September 11, 2008 09:23 Flag

I copy with that - Perhaps people need some more information about the project in order to be able to give their contributions...

Robert Seppälä September 07, 2008 16:55 Flag

Machiavelli,

I don't think most people understand the significance of the man, or his relationship with " la familia di Medici ". Perhaps it would help if you laid out a synopsis of the story you're trying to tell. Is it already written somewhere else? Tell us more about the project. What phase is the project in?

You must login or register to comment